How to Write a Reddit Comment That Isn't Spam When You Work on the Product

What Reddit's Spam policy covers

Reddit's Spam policy does not say that mentioning a product is spam. It defines spam as repeated or unsolicited actions, done by hand or by automation, that harm users, communities or Reddit itself. Its examples are patterns: mass-posting the same content for exposure or money, repeatedly dropping off-topic or link-farmed content into conversations, a bot that keeps promoting a product, link-masking or redirects to harmful domains.

The same page says how to avoid the label: post where you have a personal interest, and if most of what you share is links to a business you benefit from, think about how often you post, or consider Reddit's self-serve ads. Rule 2 of the Reddit Rules says the same thing in one line: take part authentically where you have a personal interest, and don't spam.

One relevant, disclosed answer in a thread that asked for it is not what the policy describes. Ten near-identical answers in ten threads is. Community rules can still ban any product mention; our guide to Reddit self-promotion rules covers how to find and read them.

The five parts of a useful answer

A comment that survives in a busy thread usually has the same parts in the same order. Readers and moderators tend to decide early whether it is about them or about you.

The product is the least important part. If the comment falls apart without the product name, it was an ad sitting in a thread.

The disclosure line, and where it goes

Reddit lets you stay anonymous. Its Impersonation policy says you do not have to use your real name or reveal your identity, but you may not misrepresent your identity or your affiliation to mislead people. Rule 5 puts it as: be authentic, and do not intentionally mislead others. You can keep your name private; you cannot pass as an unconnected user while recommending your own product.

In the US, the FTC's Endorsement Guides say the same thing in legal terms. Under 16 CFR 255.5, a connection between the person recommending something and the seller must be disclosed clearly and conspicuously when it could change how much weight readers give the recommendation and readers would not expect it. Business relationships, payment and free products are all listed as examples. One of the rule's own examples fits this guide exactly: an employee of a manufacturer promotes its new product on an online discussion board without saying where they work, and the rule says that person should clearly disclose the employment.

The FTC's Q&A on the Guides rules out two shortcuts. A profile naming your employer is not enough, since readers may never open it, and a tag like '#employee' may not be understood. The FTC says readers are more likely to understand 'I work for XYZ', and that plain words like 'my company's' in the message are clearer still.

• Put it next to the mention. The sentence that names the product, or the next one, says you work on it.
• Use plain words. 'I work on X' says it. 'I'm involved with this space' does not.
• Don't bury it. A disclosure tucked into the last line, after the pitch, is easy to miss, and the FTC standard is clear and conspicuous.
• Say it every time. Each comment is read on its own, so each one needs its own disclosure.

How the disclosure reads is the operator's decision; Reddit's rules and the law require the connection to be disclosed. Other countries have their own law. See the disclosure templates for wording you can adapt, and our guide to EU disclosure rules for Europe.

Links: when they help and when to leave them out

A link is not spam by itself. It becomes one when it does the work the comment should have done.

• Add it when it points to a page that answers the exact question: a setup doc, a comparison table you maintain, a public changelog entry.
• Leave it out when it points to a homepage, a pricing page or a signup form. The product name is enough; anyone interested can search it.
• Never mask it. Shorteners and redirects hide where a link goes, and Reddit's Spam policy lists link-masking and redirects to harmful domains among the things that may break it.
• Check the community first. Community rules can restrict links, and if your account is new, read why comments from new accounts get hidden before you post.

Using AI to draft: what Reddit's policy asks

Reddit's Manipulated Content policy says content made or changed with generative AI is generally allowed, subject to each community's rules and the Reddit Rules. It prohibits AI content that misleads people about real events or people, or that presents itself as human-written, and asks you to tag or otherwise indicate AI-made content.

That leaves two honest routes: use AI to research or outline, then write the comment yourself from your own experience, or post the AI draft and say so. AI text dressed up to read as a person's is what the policy rules out, whichever tool wrote it, ours included.

Copy-paste is a separate problem. Reddit's Responsible Builder Policy, which covers apps built on Reddit data, says apps must not post identical or substantially similar content across subreddits and must get a user's explicit consent before private messages. The same idea holds when you write by hand: one comment, written for one thread.

If you use Agent Agency, Approve mode makes every post, comment and DM wait for your OK, so you decide whether a reply names the product, how the disclosure reads and whether to say AI drafted it.

Five patterns that read as spam

1. The same answer everywhere
   One comment pasted, or lightly reworded, into every thread that matches a keyword. It is the pattern Reddit's Spam policy describes first, and regular readers notice it fast.
2. The answer to a different question
   The poster asked how to export their data from one tool; the comment explains why a different tool is better. If you can't answer what was asked, don't reply.
3. The hidden maker
   'A friend told me about X and it's been great.' Recommending your own product as if you were a customer is the misrepresented affiliation the Impersonation policy and the FTC both address.
4. The link-first comment
   A link with a sentence of praise around it and no answer. If the comment only works when someone clicks, it is an ad.
5. The pull to private messages
   'DM me and I'll set you up.' Reddit's Spam policy names sending large amounts of unsolicited private messages, so never message people who did not ask. Even an invited DM moves the answer out of public view, where nobody else can use it or check it.

One more, outside the text: asking coworkers to pile into the thread to push your answer. Rule 2 lists content manipulation alongside spam.

Before and after: one comment rewritten

Before: 'You need Quillbill! It's the best invoicing tool for freelancers and sends automatic reminders so you never chase anyone again. Try it free at our site.'

After: 'What worked for me was putting the reminder schedule in the contract: a polite note on the due date, a firmer one seven days later, and a late fee from day 30. Clients stopped treating reminders as personal because they had agreed to them up front. A recurring calendar reminder to send them by hand works fine, and an invoicing tool can automate it. I work on Quillbill, which is one of those, so weigh that. The contract clause did more than any tool.'

The rewrite answers first, gives a detail the reader can copy, offers an option the writer does not sell, discloses right next to the mention and drops the link. The product went from the subject to one line.

Checklist before you hit reply

• Does the first sentence answer the question the poster asked?
• Is there something in it that only someone who has done the work would know?
• Did you name at least one option you have no stake in, where one fits?
• If the product is mentioned, does the same comment say you work on it, in plain words?
• Is the link, if any, to a page that answers the question, with no shortener?
• Did you write this comment for this thread, not paste it from another?
• If AI drafted it, did you rewrite it in your own words or say that AI drafted it?
• Do the community's rules allow product mentions here at all?

For tool-request threads, see answering 'what tool do you use?' threads; for criticism of your product, see the negative thread guide.

Questions

Is it against Reddit's rules to mention my own product in a comment?

Not by itself. Reddit's Spam policy targets repeated or unsolicited activity, such as mass-posting the same content or dropping off-topic links. A single relevant answer that says you work on the product is different. Communities can still ban product mentions, and their rules apply on top of Reddit's.

Is it enough to say where I work in my Reddit profile?

No. The FTC's guidance on endorsements says a profile that names your employer is not enough, because people reading a post may never open the profile. Reddit's Impersonation policy also asks you not to misrepresent your affiliation. Put a plain sentence such as 'I work on X' in the comment, next to the mention.

Can I use ChatGPT or another AI tool to write Reddit comments?

Reddit's Manipulated Content policy generally allows AI-generated content, subject to each community's rules. It prohibits AI content that presents itself as human-written and asks you to indicate AI-made content. Write the final comment yourself, or say that AI drafted it.

How often can I mention my product on Reddit?

Reddit's Spam policy gives no number. It says that if most of your contributions are links to a business you benefit from, you should think about how often you post or consider ads. Communities can set their own limits in their rules, so check each one rather than relying on a ratio you read somewhere.

Add your product URL and a few answers while you wait for your invite. Join the waitlist