r/advertising self-promotion norms and what members ask
r/advertising opens with a warning in capitals that it is not a place to advertise and that doing so gets you banned. Behind that warning sits a room for ad creators, copywriters, students and affiliates who talk about the trade itself. This month the conversation is dominated by the holding-company shake-up around Omnicom and IPG: layoffs, return-to-office orders, retirement plan changes and culture clashes, next to a steady stream of people weighing whether to leave agency life altogether. Client-side moves, such as a streaming brand reviewing its media buying agency, come up too. For a brand, the honest reading is that this is a listening post first. Advertising gets the poster banned, shilling or fishing for free marketing gets the post removed, and posts clearly written by a chatbot are deleted with a ban, so anything said here has to come from a person speaking as a peer.
Community rules change. Read the sidebar and the pinned rules in r/advertising before you post. r/advertising on Reddit
Last reviewed by Agent Agency Editorial
About r/advertising
A community for people who make ads, from creatives and copywriters to students and affiliates, discussing the advertising business rather than advertising in it.
Common threads:
- Holding-company merger fallout: layoffs, office mandates and benefit changes
- Career exits and burnout, and where agency people go next
- Team culture inside agencies, sometimes from a freelancer's point of view
- Account and pitch news, such as a brand reviewing its agency roster
- Debates about whether the agency business is dying, including what holding-company AI platforms change
What people ask in r/advertising
- Is the traditional agency model losing ground to in-house teams and AI tools, and where should a brand put that budget instead?
- What does a holding-company merger mean for clients whose account team keeps changing?
- How does a brand run a media agency review, and what should it ask a new buying partner?
- Is an independent freelancer or small shop a safer bet than a network agency during a wave of layoffs?
- Which AI tools are agencies actually using for creative and media work, and which are internal showpieces?
How to answer well
- Take part only as a practitioner: add a concrete account of how a campaign, pitch or team change played out, with no product attached.
- Have a person write and post anything here; the rules ban posts clearly generated by a chatbot and ban their authors.
- Back a view on industry news with a source and a full link; unsourced rants, screenshots and shortened links are removed.
- On questions about where the agency business is heading, compare models (network, independent, in-house, freelance) with their trade-offs instead of steering toward a vendor.
When not to post
- Layoff, burnout and career-exit threads; people there are losing a job, not shopping for one.
- Any thread where mentioning your product or service would be the point of the comment.
- Requests for free marketing work, surveys or homework help, which the rules remove anyway.
Reported self-promotion norms
Reported by r/advertising rules page, not confirmed by a second source: The rules list is blunt: advertisements and spam mean removal and a ban, and anyone who wants to advertise is pointed to Reddit's own ad platform. A separate low-quality rule removes posts or comments that are "a poor attempt to shill or sell a product or service", that look for free marketing instead of paying a professional, or that are a few sentences with a link to a blog. The sub is for professionals to talk about advertising, "not for advertising product/services". Links through URL shorteners are removed, surveys and homework requests are not allowed, and posts clearly generated by ChatGPT or another chatbot are deleted and the user banned. The sidebar repeats that this is not a place to advertise. No promotion thread, flair requirement, or karma or account-age gate is mentioned.
- r/advertising rules page, accessed
Alternatives to r/advertising: similar subreddits
Questions
Does r/advertising allow self-promotion?
Reported by r/advertising rules page, not confirmed by a second source: The rules list is blunt: advertisements and spam mean removal and a ban, and anyone who wants to advertise is pointed to Reddit's own ad platform. A separate low-quality rule removes posts or comments that are "a poor attempt to shill or sell a product or service", that look for free marketing instead of paying a professional, or that are a few sentences with a link to a blog. The sub is for professionals to talk about advertising, "not for advertising product/services". Links through URL shorteners are removed, surveys and homework requests are not allowed, and posts clearly generated by ChatGPT or another chatbot are deleted and the user banned. The sidebar repeats that this is not a place to advertise. No promotion thread, flair requirement, or karma or account-age gate is mentioned. Read the sidebar and the pinned rules in r/advertising before you post.
How should a brand answer questions in r/advertising?
Take part only as a practitioner: add a concrete account of how a campaign, pitch or team change played out, with no product attached. Have a person write and post anything here; the rules ban posts clearly generated by a chatbot and ban their authors.
When should a brand not post in r/advertising?
Layoff, burnout and career-exit threads; people there are losing a job, not shopping for one. Any thread where mentioning your product or service would be the point of the comment.