r/agencynewbies self-promotion norms and what members ask
r/agencynewbies is where people starting a social media or digital marketing agency, often solo, bring the problems of the first year. Experienced owners are pointed to r/agency. The strongest posts are field reports with numbers: a stack of cold calls to local businesses, years of cold email copy and the replies it drew, a first AI search add-on sold to existing clients. Around them sit plainer questions about landing a first client, one account eating most of the week, late invoices and paying contractors abroad. Most top titles open with a country or region tag. The written rules are strict for vendors: no pitching, links only to free and relevant resources, no selling by DM and no AI-generated content. A brand earns its place here by teaching from real agency work, in public, with nothing to sign up for.
Community rules change. Read the sidebar and the pinned rules in r/agencynewbies before you post. r/agencynewbies on Reddit
Last reviewed by Agent Agency Editorial
About r/agencynewbies
A community for new and aspiring social media and digital marketing agency owners, mostly solo operators and small shops, with more established owners sent to r/agency.
Common threads:
- Prospecting field reports with volumes and reply rates from cold email or cold calling
- First-client struggles from owners who left a job and have only one or two accounts
- Client concentration and workload problems, such as one account taking most of the time
- Back-office questions: paying contractors abroad, chasing invoices, collecting client approvals
- Going from freelancer to agency, picking a niche and choosing which skills to build first
What people ask in r/agencynewbies
- Which acquisition channel gives a brand-new agency its first clients fastest: cold email, cold calls or partnerships?
- How can a small agency pay overseas contractors without running three separate payment apps?
- What tool lets a small web agency gather client feedback and sign-offs in one place?
- How should an agency package and price an AI search visibility add-on for clients it already has?
- Is it worth paying an outside researcher for prospect or client research, and what does that usually involve?
- Where do you find good cold email leads for small businesses in another country?
How to answer well
- Answer prospecting questions with your own figures: how many emails or calls, what reply rate, and what you changed between rounds.
- For a back-office question such as contractor payments or approvals, compare two or three options with their downsides; if you link anything, make it a free guide, never a pricing or signup page.
- Keep every answer in the thread; offering to continue in DMs breaks a rule here that leads to a ban.
- Have a person write each reply and tie it to the poster's actual numbers and niche; the rules do not tolerate AI-generated content.
When not to post
- Threads from someone who quit a job and is short on clients; any product mention there reads as preying on a worried beginner.
- Questions whose only honest answer is your own paid service, since pitching is banned outright.
- Posts looking for leads, partners or a second agency to share work, unless you can help without selling anything.
Reported self-promotion norms
Reported by r/agencynewbies rules page, not confirmed by a second source: The rules page, read today, bans spam and links Reddit's own self-promotion guidance. Under "Give More Than You Take" it says this is not a place for agency owners to be sold to: members may link to free resources but "may NOT pitch a product or service", links must be relevant and lead to a resource rather than a landing page, and post and comment history is reviewed when removing content. Messaging members to sell services, software or get leads is grounds for an immediate ban, and so is asking people to DM you. Spam or AI-generated content "will not be tolerated". No promotion thread, promo day, flair requirement or karma or account-age gate is listed.
- r/agencynewbies rules page, accessed
Alternatives to r/agencynewbies: similar subreddits
Questions
Does r/agencynewbies allow self-promotion?
Reported by r/agencynewbies rules page, not confirmed by a second source: The rules page, read today, bans spam and links Reddit's own self-promotion guidance. Under "Give More Than You Take" it says this is not a place for agency owners to be sold to: members may link to free resources but "may NOT pitch a product or service", links must be relevant and lead to a resource rather than a landing page, and post and comment history is reviewed when removing content. Messaging members to sell services, software or get leads is grounds for an immediate ban, and so is asking people to DM you. Spam or AI-generated content "will not be tolerated". No promotion thread, promo day, flair requirement or karma or account-age gate is listed. Read the sidebar and the pinned rules in r/agencynewbies before you post.
How should a brand answer questions in r/agencynewbies?
Answer prospecting questions with your own figures: how many emails or calls, what reply rate, and what you changed between rounds. For a back-office question such as contractor payments or approvals, compare two or three options with their downsides; if you link anything, make it a free guide, never a pricing or signup page.
When should a brand not post in r/agencynewbies?
Threads from someone who quit a job and is short on clients; any product mention there reads as preying on a worried beginner. Questions whose only honest answer is your own paid service, since pitching is banned outright.