# r/YouTubeCreators self-promotion norms and what members ask

r/YouTubeCreators is built for YouTube partners and creators who are still growing, and its description openly lists cross-promotion and collaboration next to video strategy and the business side of the platform; about.json showed 123,122 subscribers on 2026-11-09. The month's top posts are mostly celebrations: monetization approvals, first payouts as small as one dollar, a first long-form video passing a million views, and a full year of earnings laid out. Around them sit questions about what Shorts pay, faceless channels, uploading almost daily, and how AI-made videos compare with original work. Sharing your own channel and milestones is explicitly welcome here. Commercial advertising is a different matter: promoting a business or service to win paying customers needs the moderators' permission before anything is posted.

Community rules change. Read the sidebar and the pinned rules in r/YouTubeCreators before you post. [r/YouTubeCreators on Reddit](https://www.reddit.com/r/YouTubeCreators/)

Last reviewed November 9, 2026 by Agent Agency Editorial

[Join the waitlist](https://agentagency.si/waitlist)

## About r/YouTubeCreators

A forum for YouTube partners and growing channels to discuss video strategy, collaborate, cross-promote and talk through the creative and business sides of YouTube.

Common threads:

- Monetization milestones: approval emails, first payouts and early monthly results
- Earnings reports for specific formats such as faceless gossip channels and Shorts
- Upload-frequency experiments, such as a month of near-daily posting
- Long-form versus Shorts, with posts arguing that long-form still works
- AI-made videos versus original work, and what happened after switching away from low-effort AI content
- Channel-growth beliefs, such as new channels and shadow bans, or never deleting old videos

## What people ask in r/YouTubeCreators

- How long does it take a new channel to get monetized, and what does early revenue look like?
- How much do Shorts pay compared with long-form videos?
- Does posting almost every day speed up channel growth?
- Do faceless or AI-assisted channels still work, or does low-effort AI content hold a channel back?
- Should creators delete old videos that underperformed?

## How to answer well

- Share lessons tied to real channel numbers, the way milestone posts here pair results with advice.
- Email the moderators before posting anything that promotes a business, service or course; the rules require their permission first.
- Pay it forward in feedback threads with specific notes on titles, thumbnails or pacing.
- Keep any AI-assisted writing within reason and in your own voice; the rules allow AI-written content but not spam or low-effort posts.

## When not to post

- Celebration threads for a first payout or monetization approval; congratulate if you like, but never turn them into a pitch.
- Any promotion of a paid tool, service or course that the mod team has not approved in advance.
- Comments that drift away from the original topic, which the no-threadjacking rule covers.

## Reported self-promotion norms

Reported by r/YouTubeCreators rules page, not confirmed by a second source: The rules separate creators' own work from commercial promotion. A "Milestones + Self-Promo" rule allows and encourages both, inviting members to share wins from a first dollar to 100,000 subscribers, ideally with advice attached. A "No Advertising" rule, set on posts, bars promoting a business, service or third-party materials to gather customers and paying users unless the mod team has given permission first, through the contact address in the community description. Posts must relate to YouTube content creation and its related disciplines, low-effort posts are discouraged, and spam and farming for karma are not allowed. AI-written content is allowed "within reason". Members who ask for feedback are asked to help others in return.

- [r/YouTubeCreators rules page](https://www.reddit.com/mod/YouTubeCreators/rules/), accessed November 9, 2026

## Alternatives to r/YouTubeCreators: similar subreddits

- [r/NewTubers](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/newtubers)
- [r/PartneredYoutube](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/partneredyoutube)
- [r/SmallYoutubers](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/smallyoutubers)
- [r/YouTubers](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/youtubers)
- [r/ContentCreators](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/contentcreators)
- [r/artificial](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/artificial)
- [r/buildinpublic](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/buildinpublic)
- [r/letsplay](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/letsplay)

## Questions

### Does r/YouTubeCreators allow self-promotion?

Reported by r/YouTubeCreators rules page, not confirmed by a second source: The rules separate creators' own work from commercial promotion. A "Milestones + Self-Promo" rule allows and encourages both, inviting members to share wins from a first dollar to 100,000 subscribers, ideally with advice attached. A "No Advertising" rule, set on posts, bars promoting a business, service or third-party materials to gather customers and paying users unless the mod team has given permission first, through the contact address in the community description. Posts must relate to YouTube content creation and its related disciplines, low-effort posts are discouraged, and spam and farming for karma are not allowed. AI-written content is allowed "within reason". Members who ask for feedback are asked to help others in return. Read the sidebar and the pinned rules in r/YouTubeCreators before you post.

### How should a brand answer questions in r/YouTubeCreators?

Share lessons tied to real channel numbers, the way milestone posts here pair results with advice. Email the moderators before posting anything that promotes a business, service or course; the rules require their permission first.

### When should a brand not post in r/YouTubeCreators?

Celebration threads for a first payout or monetization approval; congratulate if you like, but never turn them into a pitch. Any promotion of a paid tool, service or course that the mod team has not approved in advance.

[Join the waitlist](https://agentagency.si/waitlist)

---

URL: https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/youtubecreators

Other languages: [Deutsch](https://agentagency.si/de/subreddits/r/youtubecreators.md) · [Français](https://agentagency.si/fr/subreddits/r/youtubecreators.md) · [Español](https://agentagency.si/es/subreddits/r/youtubecreators.md) · [Italiano](https://agentagency.si/it/subreddits/r/youtubecreators.md) · [Nederlands](https://agentagency.si/nl/subreddits/r/youtubecreators.md) · [Português](https://agentagency.si/pt/subreddits/r/youtubecreators.md)
