# r/EtsyCommunity self-promotion norms and what members ask

r/EtsyCommunity is an unofficial meeting place for people who sell and buy on Etsy, set up in 2020 to trade experiences, problems and stories, and Reddit's about.json listed 42,194 subscribers on 2026-11-12. AI was the biggest subject this month. Sellers picked apart the new policy on AI-generated patterns and bot listings, asked whether light photo edits break the new unedited-photo requirement, and reacted to Etsy's plan to train AI on member content. The rest of the feed is shop life: buyers sending AI-altered photos to back a damage claim, a refund demand on a years-old order, listings that seem to drop out of search, copyright takedowns, and first sales and kind reviews worth celebrating. The rules ban promotional posts and send them to r/etsypromo, and that ban reaches tools and services members built for Etsy sellers.

Community rules change. Read the sidebar and the pinned rules in r/EtsyCommunity before you post. [r/EtsyCommunity on Reddit](https://www.reddit.com/r/EtsyCommunity/)

Last reviewed November 12, 2026 by Agent Agency Editorial

[Join the waitlist](https://agentagency.si/waitlist)

## About r/EtsyCommunity

An unofficial space, not affiliated with Etsy, where Etsy sellers and buyers discuss their experiences, problems and stories.

Common threads:

- Etsy's AI policy changes: bans on AI-generated patterns and bot listings, what the new guidelines allow, and what still seems unclear
- Photo rules, such as whether basic edits or a watermark break Etsy's new requirement for unedited photos
- Buyer disputes, including damage claims and one-star reviews backed by AI-altered photos, and refund demands long after delivery
- Search visibility worries: suspected de-indexing and how to win traffic back
- Intellectual property: takedowns and the hostile messages that can follow a copyright action
- Morale and milestones: first sales, proud reviews, reopening after a long break, and decisions to close a shop
- Etsy's own AI features, from a new shopping tool to training AI on seller and buyer content

## What people ask in r/EtsyCommunity

- What do Etsy's updated AI rules allow, and how do they treat patterns and listings made with AI?
- How much can a seller adjust a listing photo, or add a watermark, before it breaks Etsy's new rule on unedited photos?
- How should a seller respond when a buyer backs a damage claim or a one-star review with a photo that appears AI-altered?
- What can a shop do when its listings seem to drop out of Etsy search and traffic falls?
- How should a seller handle a copyright takedown, and threatening messages that arrive after one?
- What does Etsy's plan to train AI on seller and buyer content mean for the people who run shops?

## How to answer well

- Answer policy and dispute questions with what Etsy itself has published, and suggest contacting Etsy directly for serious issues, as the sub's own rule does.
- Keep any tool, service or program you built out of posts and feedback requests here; the promotion rule names self-made Etsy and e-commerce tools and sends promotion to r/etsypromo.
- Write posts and comments yourself and use your own images; the rules do not welcome AI-generated content, though discussing AI is fine.
- When citing a policy change or a traffic trend, link a primary source; the rules ask members not to present personal experience as fact or spread rumours without one.

## When not to post

- Threads where a seller describes a buyer dispute or explains why they are closing a shop, if all you would add is a product or service.
- Requests for beta testers or feedback on an Etsy tool you made; the promotion rule covers both.
- Hypothetical questions; the rules ask for questions about your own sales, experiences and purchases.

## Reported self-promotion norms

Reported by r/EtsyCommunity rules page, not confirmed by a second source: The rules page lists thirteen rules. One headed "No Promotional Posts" asks members not to treat the sub as free promotion: promotional posts are deleted, users who keep promoting are banned, and promotion is sent to r/etsypromo. The same rule covers asking for feedback, looking for beta testers or anything else tied to an Etsy or e-commerce tool, program or service the poster made. Shop critiques are allowed under the "Shop Critique" flair with a shop link and a few details, though a new shop's post can be removed if a linked tips page already covers most of the likely feedback. A rule headed "No Generate AI" says AI-generated posts, comments, images, shops and products are not welcome, while discussion of generative AI is allowed. Other rules require effort, ban repeated posts about the same thing and stories faked for sympathy, karma or awards, and ask members to hide other people's details, including other shops' names, in screenshots. Milestone posts are limited to set sale counts. No karma or account-age requirement is stated.

- [r/EtsyCommunity rules page](https://www.reddit.com/mod/EtsyCommunity/rules/), accessed November 12, 2026

## Alternatives to r/EtsyCommunity: similar subreddits

- [r/Etsy](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/etsy)
- [r/EtsySellers](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/etsysellers)
- [r/printondemand](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/printondemand)
- [r/shopify](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/shopify)
- [r/eBaySellerAdvice](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/ebayselleradvice)
- [r/ecommerce](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/ecommerce)
- [r/EtsyHelp](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/etsyhelp)
- [r/handmade](https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/handmade)

## Questions

### Does r/EtsyCommunity allow self-promotion?

Reported by r/EtsyCommunity rules page, not confirmed by a second source: The rules page lists thirteen rules. One headed "No Promotional Posts" asks members not to treat the sub as free promotion: promotional posts are deleted, users who keep promoting are banned, and promotion is sent to r/etsypromo. The same rule covers asking for feedback, looking for beta testers or anything else tied to an Etsy or e-commerce tool, program or service the poster made. Shop critiques are allowed under the "Shop Critique" flair with a shop link and a few details, though a new shop's post can be removed if a linked tips page already covers most of the likely feedback. A rule headed "No Generate AI" says AI-generated posts, comments, images, shops and products are not welcome, while discussion of generative AI is allowed. Other rules require effort, ban repeated posts about the same thing and stories faked for sympathy, karma or awards, and ask members to hide other people's details, including other shops' names, in screenshots. Milestone posts are limited to set sale counts. No karma or account-age requirement is stated. Read the sidebar and the pinned rules in r/EtsyCommunity before you post.

### How should a brand answer questions in r/EtsyCommunity?

Answer policy and dispute questions with what Etsy itself has published, and suggest contacting Etsy directly for serious issues, as the sub's own rule does. Keep any tool, service or program you built out of posts and feedback requests here; the promotion rule names self-made Etsy and e-commerce tools and sends promotion to r/etsypromo.

### When should a brand not post in r/EtsyCommunity?

Threads where a seller describes a buyer dispute or explains why they are closing a shop, if all you would add is a product or service. Requests for beta testers or feedback on an Etsy tool you made; the promotion rule covers both.

[Join the waitlist](https://agentagency.si/waitlist)

---

URL: https://agentagency.si/subreddits/r/etsycommunity

Other languages: [Deutsch](https://agentagency.si/de/subreddits/r/etsycommunity.md) · [Français](https://agentagency.si/fr/subreddits/r/etsycommunity.md) · [Español](https://agentagency.si/es/subreddits/r/etsycommunity.md) · [Italiano](https://agentagency.si/it/subreddits/r/etsycommunity.md) · [Nederlands](https://agentagency.si/nl/subreddits/r/etsycommunity.md) · [Português](https://agentagency.si/pt/subreddits/r/etsycommunity.md)
